Posts Tagged ‘central banks’

August 13th, 2007

2 Comments

Global Markets: The Dragon stirs

The ongoing spat between the US and China over the rate of yuan appreciation has boiled over into something more interesting.

Last night Chinese officials threatened the possibility of selling down their US treasury holdings and thereby consigning the US$ to the trashcan. The Chinese are experts at promoting the maxim “don’t throw stones in glasshouses”. They are very astute at pointing out inconsistencies in arguments no doubt employing age old Confucian wisdom.

How the relationship between China and the US will pan out is anyone’s guess but we can be clear about one thing and that is the balance of power has shifted ever so slightly. The phenomenal success of the Chinese economy, based mostly on a large manufacturing base, has given the Chinese are strong foothold in global affairs. Whereas once it was a sleeping dragon content to rule its own domain now it is a major player.

At the same time it has built a strong domestic economy and plays host to the Olympics next year. It seems the US may need China more than China needs the US.

The situation doesn’t look too good for the US. Collapsing credit markets need a steady government security base to hold it all together. Any sell of in the US Treasury market would be a real disaster sending stocks down as well as the dollar.

To some extent we’ve been through this before with the Japanese. In the mid 90s Fred Bergsten hit the headlines calling for a stronger yen. This caused the $ to fall to a record low of 79.65. He was still making this call back in 2002 when he outlined strong reasons for abandoning the Clinton “strong dollar” policy.

This delicate game was fictionalised by Tom Clancy in his book “Debt of Honour” which told of a plot to destabilise the US economy by crashing the Treasury markets and the $. Of course the US won in the end but in real life who knows what would happen. The US authorities run some major interference in the markets when required and i am sure that any severe destabilisation of financial markets would see national security considerations apply (well if they haven’t got that sorted they should!). Sadly many of Clancys’ novels end up happening in real life.

The Chinese are very tactical and astute in their political strategy and very protective of their sovereignty. It will be interesting to see how this plays out but more weakening of global markets cannot be ruled out and with the end of the credit fuelled asset price boom added into the mix cash will be king.

August 5th, 2007

Leave a comment

Volatile Markets - par for the course

It’s been an interesting week or so since the RBNZ lifted interest rates t0 a wallet popping 8.25%. The Kiwi peaked above 81cts in a nice blow off move and post rate hike and carefully worded statement it has retraced as far at 75.5cts with the Yen cross taking a battering from 97.50 to 88.50. So much for safe carry trades.

The South Korean Finance Minister made some loud noises about the carry trade implications for the Won which was a bit firm for comfort.

Look really this is just a big game. And in all games there are winners and losers. As we see domestically in NZ with the collapse of yet another finance company, its usually the average risk averse investor who takes a cold bath.

Belgian dentists and Japanese housewives watch out!

All this because irresponsible and incompetent central bankers mismanage the global monetary system.

Leveraged money is like water….it will run down until it finds a place that can hold it. Anything that looks remotely fixed will attract attention..exchange rates, interest rates etc.

In a way speculators act in harmony with natural systems. Our world is in constant flux and it is normal for systems to move as new information is incorporated. Nowhere is this more obvious than the global currency markets…each breath of news is immediately received into the price no matter how minute.

So as soon as Alan Bollard said this is enough for now, then all bets were off and the market responded accordingly. Throw in the sub-prime meltdown in the US and it turned into a rout which could continue further. As i noted previously the Kiwi was at a level worth selling and could fall much further especially if the crosses get unwound.

We shouldn’t be overly concerned because we know the system is built to generate these crises every few years. According to Fred Harrison its every 18 years for the big bust  but currency debacles happen more regularly than that…..Asia, South America, Euro land, Russia…its par for the course.

So don’t be too alarmed. Just remember what Newton said…..whats goes up always comes down….eventually.

July 20th, 2007

Leave a comment

Monetary Policy 101: time for a rewrite?

Local government rates go up followed by interest rates.

Energy prices go up followed by interest rates.

So people are made worse off by increases in prices for goods and services that they cannot easily deflect or cut back on. That’s hard.

But wait there’s more, like a boxer climbing off the floor after a big punch they are hit again even harder by interest rate rises.

And to cap it off it’s all their fault.

I must be missing something here.

The only result of this type of policy is a regular cycle of boom and bust with more and more people forced into bankruptcy for no good reason.

It could be argued that interest rates should be cut in this scenario so that people are not forced to seek higher wages to compensate.

The main concern in the inflation issue is asset and commodity prices. But really its asset prices that are the culprit. They have been driving the global economy for many years now, most notably since financial deregulation in the 80s.

Talk has surfaced recently of the Treasurer invoking a clause in the Reserve Bank Act to move the inflation target aside in order to focus on the exchange rate. Whilst this is a bit far fetched it is another symptom of the policy malaise NZ is facing.

The Reserve Bank Governor has made the same mistake many others have before him: not understand the role and process of bank credit.

It’s as simple as that.

Using an inflation target to manage an economy is like riding a bike with one eye closed. Eventually you have a write off.

July 6th, 2007

1 Comment

Financial Literacy: Yes Please

In the latest RBNZ Bulletin, alongside a paper on the transmission mechanism of monetary policy, there is a paper on financial literacy and how important this is for society as a whole. Hurrah! Well almost.

I was very excited about this paper as i think financial literacy if absolutely crucial to our education system and the success of our society. However, when I read through it I felt some disappointment because the missed the most important bit out.

Money itself: What is it? How is it made? How much of it is there? How can it be created and destroyed…………and the best one: Who makes it?

Alas it focused on issues like the time value of money, risk, return, arithmetic and stuff like that. All very good and a positive step forward but it’s not enough.

This is not unexpected though. Whenever I interrogate any government official on the issue of money their eyes glaze over or they simply express incomprehension as to what I  am going on about.

There is only one political party in NZ that understand this issue and that is the Democrats for Social Credit. They are having a conference in Christchurch this weekend and you would probably learn more from that than reading the RBNZ bulletin.

Let’s have it RBNZ!

You have made a good start but let’s have full disclosure on our money system. You know it makes sense.

June 27th, 2007

3 Comments

Currency Intervention: Kiwis don’t fly

On June 11th the RBNZ intervened in the NZ$ by selling NZ$ around the US$0.7660 level in thin markets. This was followed up by another bout or two resulting in short term sell offs to US$0.76.

This action has create a fair bit of comment most of it apoplectic in nature focusing on the poor NZ central bank against the might of global speculators. The commentary uniformly blasted the RB and trotted out the story of how George Soros buried the Bank of England back in 1992.

Well this is one time i can say “i was there” as i was actually trading Stg at the time, with the regular trader lying on a beach in the Carribean. It was a crazy time to be in the markets but when you were the focal point of action that feeling was magnified. The Bank of England phone line was running hot as we called up to sell more and more Stg. The voice on the other end of the phone was resigned to the ship going down.

It duly did. The next day i had my biggest one day loss in 12 years of trading as the market all but disappeared and every customer was looking to trade. I remember my broker took me out to dinner at the casino in Park Lane to recover. Nice.

But the main point of this story is that Stg was way overvalued and stuck in the ERM where it was required under the Maastricht Treaty to keep the Pound above a certain level which was DM2.7780.

So the Old Lady was just doing her job. She wasn’t taking on Soros or the market but just fulfilling legal obligations. Soros made a bet that the UK would have to pull out of the ERM and that was a political action and you can be sure he would have done his homework there.

So it is very different to what we see when the BOJ intervenes in the Yen at 100 or 145 where there is no legal cap but an extreme extension in rates.

The RBNZ action falls into this camp. The NZ$ is appreciating well beyond fundamentals based on the current account deficit, PPP comparisons and problems for the export sector to sell its goods. It is also suffering from carry trade side effects which are causing a huge inflow of short term investment to take advantage of high interest rates.

Its intervention is justified on those grounds. The NZ$ should be trading around US$0.60 which is just above its long term average. Of course currency rates can run way beyond what might be considered justifiable and for some period of time.

The Great Game continues in the global financial markets where the US sells it paper to trading nations such as Japan and now China in return for goods. One day this game may stop and the US$ will go into freefall.

The same could happen to the NZ$. I would say the RBNZ intervention is justified though how effective it is remains to be seen. Jeff Gamlin at the NBR is quite positive on the profit implications and it’s certainly a good long term trade to buy some foreign reserves. They should be selling as much Kiwi as possible!

As it happens intervention usually works if the intervening bank has some justification. Remember currency speculators like to make money. They don’t care whether it’s up or down.

The RBNZ is in a tight spot regardless of what Grant Spencer, the Deputy Governor , says. They will need a bit of luck to get this right and will need to continue intervening if required at higher levels like 78 and 80. I think though they will be safe there as people are starting to feel the pinch of higher rates.

Also yesterday the Japanese Minister of Finance weighed into the fray with some well placed comments. The Japanese are the experts in intervention and jawboning the currency. That shot across the bows should not be ignored.

June 27th, 2007

3 Comments

Internet Banking: Coming Soon

I’ve been following the spread of microfinance for a while and have been getting involved with Kiva which has been a great experience. I have also noted the rise of social lending businesses such as Zopa, Prosper and even Facebook. Jason has written a good piece on the rise of new forms of financing.

What interest me further is whether all finance can move to a P2P platform and seriously eat into the major lending markets currently controlled by the commercial banks.

I think it could do. This crosses the web with money and complimentary currencies.

Remember that anyone can create “money” if they really want, it just can’t be in the form of bank notes issued by the Reserve Bank. Commercial banks create bank loans by a simple bookkeeping entry. Only 2% of the money supply in NZ is in the form of notes and coin so banks don’t actually hold any money other than a bit of cash.

My point is that P2P finance could take off in a very big way once we get the hang of it. My guess is that the firms currently involved don’t realise how big this could be.

Expect the central banks to cast their beady eyes over these operations once they get a roll on. For now it’s just some web bizness but this feels like 1694 all over again.

About

I’m a Londoner who moved to Christchurch, New Zealand in 2002. After studying economics and finance at Manchester University and a couple of years of backpacking, I ended up working in the financial markets in London. I traded the global financial markets on behalf of investment banks for 11 years. I write about the intersection of economic, social and environmental issues . My prime interest is in designing better systems to create a better world. I welcome comments and input.

Follow me on

 

Twitter

Blog archives